The Dustbin . . .
Moderator: Field of Glory 2 Tournaments Managers
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Re: First and second round draw this Friday , , ,
The draw will take place in about half an hour's time. First of all I will draw the 12 first round matches involving 24 players. The 20 players who are not drawn out will get byes to the second round. Then I will draw the second round matches. The future winners of the 12 first round matches will constitute the first 6 second round matches (i.e. winner of match 3 v winner of match 11) and the 20 players receiving a bye will constitute the remaining 10 second round matches. This will result in 16 players contesting the third round. The reason for doing the draw this way is so that everyone gets a match to start on Monday. I am concerned that if I keep 20 players hanging around for another 2 weeks then some may drift away resulting in second round byes. The draw is completely unseeded so any match-up is possible. The tournament schedule is unaffected and 4 weeks will be given to complete all first and second round matches.
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Re: First and second round draw coming shortly . . .
Right then, I am going to start. I will post the matches up in pairs.
First Round draw
1. bomber23 - Seleucids 166-125 BC v ggarynorman - Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD
2. Rob123 - Sassanid Persians 591-628 AD v phoyle3290 - Macedonian 320-261 BC
3. LorneMalvo - Carthaginians (Hannibal in Africa) 202 BC v Geffalrus - Macedonians 328-321 BC
4. desertedfox - Indians 546-599 AD v sunnyboy - Byzantines 551-578 AD
5. Challenge1- Macedonians 320-261 BC v greekiraklis - Ptolemaic 166-56 BC
6. schmolywar - Ptolemaic 166-56 BC v KiFi - Macedonians 320-261 BC
7. oscarius - Dacians 89-106 AD v Nosy_Rat - Sassanids 591-628 AD
8. Sennacherib - Romans 379-424 AD v devoncop - Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD
9. Tresantes - Pyrrhic 280-272 BC v Herode_2 - Gallics 300-101 BC
10. paulmcneil - Kushans 130 BC - 476 AD v lydianed - Gepids 493-567 AD
11. SawyerK - Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD v Trogilus - Pergamenes 190-129 BC
12. Doyley50 - Romans 24 BC-196 AD v ConstantinIX - Seleucids 300-206 BC
That completes the first round draw. Any player from the 44 starters not drawn here has received a bye to the second round. I will now do the 2nd Round draw.
Second Round draw
1. Winner of Match 1 v Winner of Match 2
2. Winner of Match 3 v Winner of Match 11
3. Winner of Match 6 v Winner of Match 10
4. Winner of Match 4 v Winner of Match 5
5. Winner of Match 9 v Winner of Match 8
6. Winner of Match 7 v Winner of Match 12
7. Ulysisgrunt - Jewish Revolt 66-135 BC v CheAhn - Romans 285-312 AD
8. SpeedyCM - Carthaginians (Hannibal in Africa) 202 BC v Triarii - Visigoths 419-621 AD
9. rexhurley - Moorish 350-698 AD v Questar17 - Carthaginians 235-146 BC
10. dkalenda - Seleucids 166-125 BC v GDod - Romans 285-312 AD
11. klayeckles - Egyptians 664-571 BC v pantherboy - Indians 546-599 AD
12. XLegione - Breton 411-579 AD v Morbio - Lombards 568-569 AD
13. ianiow - Byzantium 551-578 AD v General Shapur - Samnites 355-272 BC
14. Bluefin - Macedonians 320-261 BC v IMC - Galatians 280-63 BC
15. deve - Carthaginians (Hannibal in Africa) 202 BC v MorkinTheFree - Romano-British 407-599 AD
16. harveylh - Sassanid Persian 591-628 AD v nyczar - Scots 50 BC - 476 AD
That completes the second round draw.
First Round draw
1. bomber23 - Seleucids 166-125 BC v ggarynorman - Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD
2. Rob123 - Sassanid Persians 591-628 AD v phoyle3290 - Macedonian 320-261 BC
3. LorneMalvo - Carthaginians (Hannibal in Africa) 202 BC v Geffalrus - Macedonians 328-321 BC
4. desertedfox - Indians 546-599 AD v sunnyboy - Byzantines 551-578 AD
5. Challenge1- Macedonians 320-261 BC v greekiraklis - Ptolemaic 166-56 BC
6. schmolywar - Ptolemaic 166-56 BC v KiFi - Macedonians 320-261 BC
7. oscarius - Dacians 89-106 AD v Nosy_Rat - Sassanids 591-628 AD
8. Sennacherib - Romans 379-424 AD v devoncop - Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD
9. Tresantes - Pyrrhic 280-272 BC v Herode_2 - Gallics 300-101 BC
10. paulmcneil - Kushans 130 BC - 476 AD v lydianed - Gepids 493-567 AD
11. SawyerK - Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD v Trogilus - Pergamenes 190-129 BC
12. Doyley50 - Romans 24 BC-196 AD v ConstantinIX - Seleucids 300-206 BC
That completes the first round draw. Any player from the 44 starters not drawn here has received a bye to the second round. I will now do the 2nd Round draw.
Second Round draw
1. Winner of Match 1 v Winner of Match 2
2. Winner of Match 3 v Winner of Match 11
3. Winner of Match 6 v Winner of Match 10
4. Winner of Match 4 v Winner of Match 5
5. Winner of Match 9 v Winner of Match 8
6. Winner of Match 7 v Winner of Match 12
7. Ulysisgrunt - Jewish Revolt 66-135 BC v CheAhn - Romans 285-312 AD
8. SpeedyCM - Carthaginians (Hannibal in Africa) 202 BC v Triarii - Visigoths 419-621 AD
9. rexhurley - Moorish 350-698 AD v Questar17 - Carthaginians 235-146 BC
10. dkalenda - Seleucids 166-125 BC v GDod - Romans 285-312 AD
11. klayeckles - Egyptians 664-571 BC v pantherboy - Indians 546-599 AD
12. XLegione - Breton 411-579 AD v Morbio - Lombards 568-569 AD
13. ianiow - Byzantium 551-578 AD v General Shapur - Samnites 355-272 BC
14. Bluefin - Macedonians 320-261 BC v IMC - Galatians 280-63 BC
15. deve - Carthaginians (Hannibal in Africa) 202 BC v MorkinTheFree - Romano-British 407-599 AD
16. harveylh - Sassanid Persian 591-628 AD v nyczar - Scots 50 BC - 476 AD
That completes the second round draw.
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Tournament results . . .
First Round
1. ggarynorman (Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD) beat bomber23 (Seleucids 166-125 BC) 61-36
2. phoyle3290 (Macedonians 320-261 BC) beat Rob123 (Sassanids 591-628 AD) 41-16
3. LorneMalvo (Carthaginians, Hannibal in Africa 202 BC) beat Geffalrus (Macedonians 328-321 BC) 41-31
4. sunnyboy (Byzantines 551-578 AD) beat desertedfox (Indians 546-599 AD) 43-14
5. greekiraklis (Ptolemaics 166-56 BC) beat Challenge1 (Macedonians 320-261 BC) 51-5
6. schmolywar (Ptolemaic 166-56 BC) beat KiFi (Macedonians 320-261 BC) 47-12
7. Nosy_Rat (Sassanids 591-628 AD) beat oscarius (Dacians 89-106 AD) 51-13
8. devoncop (Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD) beat Sennacherib (Romans 379-424 AD) 5-3
9. Tresantes (Pyrrhic 280-272 BC) beat Herode_2 (Gallics 300-101 BC) 44-19
10. lydianed (Gepids 493-567 AD) beat paulmcneil (Kushans 130 BC - 476 AD) 56-31
11. Trogilus (Pergamenes 190-129 BC) beat SawyerK (Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD) 52-24
12. Doyley50 (Romans 24 BC-196 AD) beat ConstantinIX (Seleucids 300-206 BC) 65-35
Second Round
1. ggarynorman (Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD) beat phoyle3290 (Macedonians 320-261 BC) 63-54
2. Trogilus (Pergamenes 190-129 BC) beat LorneMalvo (Carthaginians (Hannibal in Africa) 202 BC) 39-20
3. schmolywar (Ptolemaics 166-56 BC) beat lydianed (Gepids 493-567 AD) 68-51
4. sunnyboy (Byzantines 551-578 AD) beat greekiraklis (Ptolemaic 166-56 BC) on adjudication 2-0
5. devoncop (Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD) beat Tresantes (Pyrrhic 280-272 BC) 40-6
6. Nosy_Rat (Sassanids 591-628 AD) beat Doyley50 (Romans 24 BC-196 AD) 42-10
7. Ulysisgrunt (Jewish Revolt 66-135 BC) beat CheAhn (Romans 285-312 AD) 63-40
8. SpeedyCM (Carthaginians, Hannibal in Africa 202 BC) beat Triarii (Visigoths 419-621 AD) 62-40
9. rexhurley (Moorish 350-698 AD) beat Questar17 (Carthaginians 235-146 BC) 52-27
10. dkalenda (Seleucids 166-125 BC) beat GDod (Romans 285-312 AD) 55-22
11. klayeckles (Egyptians 664-571 BC) beat pantherboy (Indians 546-599 AD) 63-42
12. XLegione (Bretons 411-579 AD) beat Morbio (Lombards 568-569 AD) 65-42
13. ianiow (Byzantines 551-578 AD) beat General Shapur (Samnites 355-272 BC) 43-16
14. IMC (Galatians 280-63 BC) beat Bluefin (Macedonians 320-261 BC) 41-16
15. deve (Carthaginians, Hannibal in Africa 202 BC) beat MorkinTheFree (Romano-British 407-599 AD) 46-21
16. harveylh (Sassanids 591-628 AD) beat nyczar (Scots 50 BC - 476 AD) 61-59
1. ggarynorman (Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD) beat bomber23 (Seleucids 166-125 BC) 61-36
2. phoyle3290 (Macedonians 320-261 BC) beat Rob123 (Sassanids 591-628 AD) 41-16
3. LorneMalvo (Carthaginians, Hannibal in Africa 202 BC) beat Geffalrus (Macedonians 328-321 BC) 41-31
4. sunnyboy (Byzantines 551-578 AD) beat desertedfox (Indians 546-599 AD) 43-14
5. greekiraklis (Ptolemaics 166-56 BC) beat Challenge1 (Macedonians 320-261 BC) 51-5
6. schmolywar (Ptolemaic 166-56 BC) beat KiFi (Macedonians 320-261 BC) 47-12
7. Nosy_Rat (Sassanids 591-628 AD) beat oscarius (Dacians 89-106 AD) 51-13
8. devoncop (Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD) beat Sennacherib (Romans 379-424 AD) 5-3
9. Tresantes (Pyrrhic 280-272 BC) beat Herode_2 (Gallics 300-101 BC) 44-19
10. lydianed (Gepids 493-567 AD) beat paulmcneil (Kushans 130 BC - 476 AD) 56-31
11. Trogilus (Pergamenes 190-129 BC) beat SawyerK (Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD) 52-24
12. Doyley50 (Romans 24 BC-196 AD) beat ConstantinIX (Seleucids 300-206 BC) 65-35
Second Round
1. ggarynorman (Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD) beat phoyle3290 (Macedonians 320-261 BC) 63-54
2. Trogilus (Pergamenes 190-129 BC) beat LorneMalvo (Carthaginians (Hannibal in Africa) 202 BC) 39-20
3. schmolywar (Ptolemaics 166-56 BC) beat lydianed (Gepids 493-567 AD) 68-51
4. sunnyboy (Byzantines 551-578 AD) beat greekiraklis (Ptolemaic 166-56 BC) on adjudication 2-0
5. devoncop (Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD) beat Tresantes (Pyrrhic 280-272 BC) 40-6
6. Nosy_Rat (Sassanids 591-628 AD) beat Doyley50 (Romans 24 BC-196 AD) 42-10
7. Ulysisgrunt (Jewish Revolt 66-135 BC) beat CheAhn (Romans 285-312 AD) 63-40
8. SpeedyCM (Carthaginians, Hannibal in Africa 202 BC) beat Triarii (Visigoths 419-621 AD) 62-40
9. rexhurley (Moorish 350-698 AD) beat Questar17 (Carthaginians 235-146 BC) 52-27
10. dkalenda (Seleucids 166-125 BC) beat GDod (Romans 285-312 AD) 55-22
11. klayeckles (Egyptians 664-571 BC) beat pantherboy (Indians 546-599 AD) 63-42
12. XLegione (Bretons 411-579 AD) beat Morbio (Lombards 568-569 AD) 65-42
13. ianiow (Byzantines 551-578 AD) beat General Shapur (Samnites 355-272 BC) 43-16
14. IMC (Galatians 280-63 BC) beat Bluefin (Macedonians 320-261 BC) 41-16
15. deve (Carthaginians, Hannibal in Africa 202 BC) beat MorkinTheFree (Romano-British 407-599 AD) 46-21
16. harveylh (Sassanids 591-628 AD) beat nyczar (Scots 50 BC - 476 AD) 61-59
Re: Tournament results . . .
Klay v Pantherboy
Love it. Barcelona v Real Madrid 1st Round.
Love it. Barcelona v Real Madrid 1st Round.
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Arrange your matches here . . .
Either player may set up a match in this tournament. Remember to PM your opponent as well as placing the challenge and password in this thread.
For matches in this tournament players will select "Open Battle" and will field a "Medium" army and choose a "Medium" battlefield unless otherwise directed. Players are free to customise their army before each battle so "Default" is the correct Force Selection option. Terrain will always be "Pot Luck" unless otherwise specified. There are no exceptions to this standard set-up for a match. If a match is set-up incorrectly for any reason then it must be re-started as soon as possible.
Please be sure to familiarise yourself with the Rules of Competition.
http://www.slitherine.com/forum/viewtop ... 11&t=82761
For matches in this tournament players will select "Open Battle" and will field a "Medium" army and choose a "Medium" battlefield unless otherwise directed. Players are free to customise their army before each battle so "Default" is the correct Force Selection option. Terrain will always be "Pot Luck" unless otherwise specified. There are no exceptions to this standard set-up for a match. If a match is set-up incorrectly for any reason then it must be re-started as soon as possible.
Please be sure to familiarise yourself with the Rules of Competition.
http://www.slitherine.com/forum/viewtop ... 11&t=82761
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Winners post your results here . . .
Reporting the result of a match is the responsibility of the winning player. However, if you are the loser in a match and notice that the result has not been posted within 24 hours please post the result yourself.
The final % scores for each player are taken from the in-battle display in the top left-hand corner of the screen and not the Battle Summary screen that appears after the battle has ended where losses are adjusted for wounded and deserted troops.
Please use the following format to report your victories . . .
1st Round
hidde (Carthaginians) beat stockwellpete (Pyrrhics) 54-29
The final % scores for each player are taken from the in-battle display in the top left-hand corner of the screen and not the Battle Summary screen that appears after the battle has ended where losses are adjusted for wounded and deserted troops.
Please use the following format to report your victories . . .
1st Round
hidde (Carthaginians) beat stockwellpete (Pyrrhics) 54-29
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Re: Tournament diary and news . . .
The first and second round draws have now been made and PM's with the details have been sent out to everyone. The tournament opens on Monday 1st April.
The entry list for the 2019 tournament is as follows . . .
1. Bluefin - Macedonians 320-261 BC
2. bomber23 - Seleucids 166-125 BC
3. Challenge1- Macedonians 320-261 BC
4. CheAhn - Romans 285-312 AD
5. ConstantinIX - Seleucids 300-206 BC
6. desertedfox - Indians 546-599 AD
7. deve - Carthaginians (Hannibal in Africa) 202 BC
8. devoncop - Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD
9. dkalenda - Seleucids 166-125 BC
10. Doyley50 - Romans 24 BC-196 AD
11. GDod - Romans 285-312 AD
12. Geffalrus - Macedonians 328-321 BC
13. General Shapur - Samnites 355-272 BC
14. ggarynorman - Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD
15. greekiraklis - Ptolemaic 166-56 BC
16. harveylh - Sassanid Persian 591-628 AD
17. Herode_2 - Gallics 300-101 BC
18. ianiow - Byzantium 551-578 AD
19. IMC - Galatians 280-63 BC
20. KiFi - Macedonians 320-261 BC
21. klayeckles - Egyptians 664-571 BC
22. LorneMalvo - Carthaginians (Hannibal in Africa) 202 BC
23. lydianed - Gepids 493-567 AD
24. Morbio - Lombards 568-569 AD
25. MorkinTheFree - Romano-British 407-599 AD
26. Nosy_Rat - Sassanids 591-628 AD
27. nyczar - Scots 50 BC - 476 AD
28. oscarius - Dacians 89-106 AD
29. paulmcneil - Kushans 130 BC - 476 AD
30. pantherboy - Indians 546-599 AD
31. phoyle3290 - Macedonian 320-261 BC
32. Questar17 - Carthaginians 235-146 BC
33. rexhurley - Moorish 350-698 AD
34. Rob123 - Sassanid Persians 591-628 AD
35. SawyerK - Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD
36. schmolywar - Ptolemaic 166-56 BC
37. Sennacherib - Romans 379-424 AD
38. SpeedyCM - Carthaginians (Hannibal in Africa) 202 BC
39. sunnyboy - Byzantines 551-578 AD
40. Tresantes - Pyrrhic 280-272 BC
41. Triarii - Visigoths 419-621 AD
42. Trogilus - Pergamenes 190-129 BC
43. Ulysisgrunt - Jewish Revolt 66-135 BC
44. XLegione - Breton 411-579 AD
The following players failed to submit their army by the deadline and were not included in the draw . . . Aeneas Stator, jjaquemond, mkjhartmann, Nijis and Olias. If any of these players wish to submit an army now they may do so and then they can be placed on the reserve list. It is possible that we will have a non-starter somewhere in the tournament.
First reserve - Olias - Carthaginians 235-146 BC
The entry list for the 2019 tournament is as follows . . .
1. Bluefin - Macedonians 320-261 BC
2. bomber23 - Seleucids 166-125 BC
3. Challenge1- Macedonians 320-261 BC
4. CheAhn - Romans 285-312 AD
5. ConstantinIX - Seleucids 300-206 BC
6. desertedfox - Indians 546-599 AD
7. deve - Carthaginians (Hannibal in Africa) 202 BC
8. devoncop - Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD
9. dkalenda - Seleucids 166-125 BC
10. Doyley50 - Romans 24 BC-196 AD
11. GDod - Romans 285-312 AD
12. Geffalrus - Macedonians 328-321 BC
13. General Shapur - Samnites 355-272 BC
14. ggarynorman - Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD
15. greekiraklis - Ptolemaic 166-56 BC
16. harveylh - Sassanid Persian 591-628 AD
17. Herode_2 - Gallics 300-101 BC
18. ianiow - Byzantium 551-578 AD
19. IMC - Galatians 280-63 BC
20. KiFi - Macedonians 320-261 BC
21. klayeckles - Egyptians 664-571 BC
22. LorneMalvo - Carthaginians (Hannibal in Africa) 202 BC
23. lydianed - Gepids 493-567 AD
24. Morbio - Lombards 568-569 AD
25. MorkinTheFree - Romano-British 407-599 AD
26. Nosy_Rat - Sassanids 591-628 AD
27. nyczar - Scots 50 BC - 476 AD
28. oscarius - Dacians 89-106 AD
29. paulmcneil - Kushans 130 BC - 476 AD
30. pantherboy - Indians 546-599 AD
31. phoyle3290 - Macedonian 320-261 BC
32. Questar17 - Carthaginians 235-146 BC
33. rexhurley - Moorish 350-698 AD
34. Rob123 - Sassanid Persians 591-628 AD
35. SawyerK - Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD
36. schmolywar - Ptolemaic 166-56 BC
37. Sennacherib - Romans 379-424 AD
38. SpeedyCM - Carthaginians (Hannibal in Africa) 202 BC
39. sunnyboy - Byzantines 551-578 AD
40. Tresantes - Pyrrhic 280-272 BC
41. Triarii - Visigoths 419-621 AD
42. Trogilus - Pergamenes 190-129 BC
43. Ulysisgrunt - Jewish Revolt 66-135 BC
44. XLegione - Breton 411-579 AD
The following players failed to submit their army by the deadline and were not included in the draw . . . Aeneas Stator, jjaquemond, mkjhartmann, Nijis and Olias. If any of these players wish to submit an army now they may do so and then they can be placed on the reserve list. It is possible that we will have a non-starter somewhere in the tournament.
First reserve - Olias - Carthaginians 235-146 BC
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Re: Tournament results . . .
Yes, I thought something like that might happen when most of the top-rated players avoided being drawn in the first round. So there was pantherboy, klayeckles, ianiow, dkalenda, Triarii, harveylh and CheAhn all waiting to be drawn out in the second round matches.
Re: The Discussion thread . . .
Nicely done.
Speaking on behalf of the mediocrities "more of that" please
Speaking on behalf of the mediocrities "more of that" please
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Slitherine are sponsoring the KO Tournament again!
Slitherine have agreed to sponsor the 2019 KO Tournament with 2 x $25 vouchers to be spent in the Slitherine store. Both finalists will receive one voucher each. My thanks to Daniele and Marco at Slitherine for their continued support.
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Re: Winners post your results here . . .
First and second round matches start here.
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Re: Arrange your matches here . . .
First and second round matches start here.
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
The Tournament is now open!
You can start your first or second round matches now. Good luck everyone!
-
- Brigadier-General - Elite Grenadier
- Posts: 2164
- Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 4:40 pm
- Location: Wokingham, UK
Re: Arrange your matches here . . .
Morbio (Lombard) vs XLegione (Breton) is underway. I will be away in Lombardy (coincidentally) until Thursday night so there will be a brief hiatus for a few days while I personally inspect my troops!
Re: Arrange your matches here . . .
2nd Round
harveylh - Sassanid Persian 591-628 AD challenges nyczar - Scots 50 BC - 476 AD, password czar, pm sent
harveylh - Sassanid Persian 591-628 AD challenges nyczar - Scots 50 BC - 476 AD, password czar, pm sent
We should all Stand With Ukraine.
-
- Senior Corporal - Destroyer
- Posts: 115
- Joined: Thu Jan 10, 2019 7:42 pm
- Location: NC, USA
Re: Arrange your matches here . . .
phoyle3290 (Macedonian 320-261) challenges Rob 123 (Sassanid Persians 591-628 AD), password Rob123, pm sent
Re: Arrange your matches here . . .
deve (Hannibal in Africa) challenges MorkinTheFree (Romano-British)
password: 1234
password: 1234
Re: Arrange your matches here . . .
devoncop (Jewish Revolt) challenges Sennacherib (Rome 379)
Password : tournament
PM sent
Password : tournament
PM sent
Re: Arrange your matches here . . .
Second Round:
rexhurley (Moorish) challenges Questar17 (Carthiginians) Pw = Tourney
rexhurley (Moorish) challenges Questar17 (Carthiginians) Pw = Tourney
-
- Sergeant - 7.5 cm FK 16 nA
- Posts: 234
- Joined: Sat Nov 21, 2009 7:37 pm
Re: Arrange your matches here . . .
ggarynorman challenges Bomber 23 pw ggarynorman PM sent