Table of Honour
Moderators: pantherboy, Slitherine Core, NewRoSoft
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Hidde, I don't know if I am imagining things, but didn't you post up an "Olympic-style" LOEG medals table at one stage? I thought that it was a good idea at the time but I had one major difference with it.
The medal table reflected (quite logically) who came 1st, 2nd and 3rd in Division A of each expansion pack - but this made it of interest primarily to just a narrow band of the very top players. To have made it more interesting I thought that "gold medals" should be awarded to the winners of Div A, "silver medals" to the winners of Div B, and "bronze medals" to the winners of any other division. In this way you would get a broader range of names included in the table and it would have made it more interesting.
What do you think?
The medal table reflected (quite logically) who came 1st, 2nd and 3rd in Division A of each expansion pack - but this made it of interest primarily to just a narrow band of the very top players. To have made it more interesting I thought that "gold medals" should be awarded to the winners of Div A, "silver medals" to the winners of Div B, and "bronze medals" to the winners of any other division. In this way you would get a broader range of names included in the table and it would have made it more interesting.
What do you think?
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
-
- General - Carrier
- Posts: 4999
- Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2009 2:42 pm
Hmm, if players are grouped in divisions based on skill/performance relative to others in a divison, methinks that achievement is the same for coming in ist second third regardless of if its the A , b etc... Thus all division placers should be eligable for the shiny trinkets.stockwellpete wrote:Hidde, I don't know if I am imagining things, but didn't you post up an "Olympic-style" LOEG medals table at one stage? I thought that it was a good idea at the time but I had one major difference with it.
The medal table reflected (quite logically) who came 1st, 2nd and 3rd in Division A of each expansion pack - but this made it of interest primarily to just a narrow band of the very top players. To have made it more interesting I thought that "gold medals" should be awarded to the winners of Div A, "silver medals" to the winners of Div B, and "bronze medals" to the winners of any other division. In this way you would get a broader range of names included in the table and it would have made it more interesting.
What do you think?
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Yes, I like your idea more than my own suggestion, TGM. That really would be a way of increasing interest in the table - and hopefully in the LOEG competition as a whole.TheGrayMouser wrote: Hmm, if players are grouped in divisions based on skill/performance relative to others in a divison, methinks that achievement is the same for coming in ist second third regardless of if its the A , b etc... Thus all division placers should be eligable for the shiny trinkets.
That's a good suggestion. I'll do that, CC and the rest when season 5 is over.stockwellpete wrote:Yes, I like your idea more than my own suggestion, TGM. That really would be a way of increasing interest in the table - and hopefully in the LOEG competition as a whole.TheGrayMouser wrote: Hmm, if players are grouped in divisions based on skill/performance relative to others in a divison, methinks that achievement is the same for coming in ist second third regardless of if its the A , b etc... Thus all division placers should be eligable for the shiny trinkets.
-
- General - Carrier
- Posts: 4999
- Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2009 2:42 pm
hurray, now my glory day , season 2, E division will be immortalizedhidde wrote:That's a good suggestion. I'll do that, CC and the rest when season 5 is over.stockwellpete wrote:Yes, I like your idea more than my own suggestion, TGM. That really would be a way of increasing interest in the table - and hopefully in the LOEG competition as a whole.TheGrayMouser wrote: Hmm, if players are grouped in divisions based on skill/performance relative to others in a divison, methinks that achievement is the same for coming in ist second third regardless of if its the A , b etc... Thus all division placers should be eligable for the shiny trinkets.
I'm sorry GTM but I kind of thought I should skip D & E divisions. They only existed the first two seasons and frankly, I doubt there will be more than three divisions in the vast majority of future Leagues.TheGrayMouser wrote:hurray, now my glory day , season 2, E division will be immortalizedhidde wrote:That's a good suggestion. I'll do that, CC and the rest when season 5 is over.stockwellpete wrote: Yes, I like your idea more than my own suggestion, TGM. That really would be a way of increasing interest in the table - and hopefully in the LOEG competition as a whole.
If it does no problem to add them later
Re: Table of Honour
Updated.
Please report if spotting any error.
Please report if spotting any error.
Re: Table of Honour
No shared victory positions for Div C Imperial?(I tied with Cytus)
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14500
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Re: Table of Honour
Players level on points are split with reference to the "Kill ratio". There is a separate column in the table for that. It is like goal difference in football.Tiavals wrote:No shared victory positions for Div C Imperial?(I tied with Cytus)
Anders, I can only see the left-hand side of your chart, I think.
Re: Table of Honour
So it's better to have an army that has high quality units as opposed to rabble? I guess it makes sense, since many armies can take loads of cheap filler.
Re: Table of Honour
It's the new forum that have less space to display pictures. For some (stupid) reason the column with user name are much wider now.Anders, I can only see the left-hand side of your chart, I think.
I have already rearranged all the charts and on my screen all but the K-O chart are visible.
I belive all of that one can be seen if you have wide-screen and I don't think the text should be any smaller.
Or the designer could have thought of a scrollbar...
Re: Table of Honour
Updated.
Please report if spotting any error.
Please report if spotting any error.
Re: Table of Honour
At least I got a 3rd place
Re: Table of Honour
Update